A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

Author: Holly Jackson
Publisher: Ember
Genre: young adult, mystery, thriller
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5


Trigger Warnings: Suicide
Trope: Culprit isn’t one of the suspects


It was such a great mystery book. I never expected the story to go the way it had. It was a roller coaster of mystery and intrigue. It was really crazy. I definitely loved how Pip goes around and starts uncovering the truth about Andie and it was just wild.

I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who likes a good mystery with a lot of twists and turns. Begrudgingly, there’s a little bit of romance but at least our main character knows she needs to solve the mystery first before getting into a relationship. But yes it’s a great mystery and even for a young adult it was a great read.

If you are sensitive to suicide, please note there is a murder made to look like suicide involving pills. If that is a trigger for you, maybe it’s best not to read this book. You’ll pretty much be able to question whether it really was a suicide, which obviously not, but just in case. Be warned.

I would definitely reread this book AFTER I read the rest of the series. I like rereading entire series in completion so if the rest isn‘t really a reread, I might not reread this one. But I absolutely loved it and would love to read again.

I enjoyed this mystery writing style very much. I am in love with twists and turns and the totally unexpected. Being close to solving the mystery only for something completely different popping up that throws everything out the window. Love it!

It took four day for me to read it and it’s because I had to force myself to put the book down. I used to love reading books in a single day, but I don’t feel like I’m digesting the whole book if I read it nonstop for a day. So I’ve been trying to stretch the reading out. Maybe a couple reading sessions a day or next chapter put it down and pick it up again tomorrow. I’ve got other things to do these days. But I still loved this book and couldn’t put it down without struggle.

I like to think that I’d be just as driven as Pip in solving this case and I would be just as devastated as the suspects families once the case was solved. I might even become obsessed with solving a case. But Pip’s uncertainty about who she is and yet the certainty that she must solve this murder, that’s pretty relatable.

Great book, great characters, great mystery. I will definitely go on and read the next book in the series and hopefully come back and reread A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.


2022 Reading Goal

Book #8 out of 50

2022 Reading Challenge

None